Dr. Andrew Weil Still Promoting Fluoride Use

Dr. Andrew Weil Still Promoting Fluoride Use

drweilIn a recent Prevention magazine article I was shocked to read the answer to a question asked by a reader to Dr. Andrew Weil. With all the negative and scientific proof out there on the dangers of fluoride ingestion, I find this alarming that a doctor as well known and respected as Dr. Weil would still be promoting fluoride use. While the following article does not speak of fluoride in drinking water, he is still promoting its use in fluoride toothpaste. Here is the complete article:

“Q: I’ve been using fluoride-free natural toothpaste for years. Should I switch? 
–Amy McCormick, Zionsville, PA

A: Yes. I recommend you use a toothpaste that contains fluoride to prevent cavities and strengthen tooth enamel. While I hear claims about the hazards of the mineral, I think they’re exaggerated. It is toxic only in large doses.

I prefer to brush with toothpaste that also contains an ingredient called chlorine dioxide—a disinfectant that appears to help rid the mouth of bacteria—and is free of synthetic dyes and sodium lauryl sulfate, a foaming agent that has been associated with skin irritation and recurrent canker sores. Some big-box stores and most health-food stores carry many brands that do not contain those ingredients but do contain fluoride.

Over-the-counter whitening toothpastes are also safe, though they may increase tooth sensitivity in susceptible individuals, such as children under 16 years of age, people with untreated cavities, people who’ve had their teeth professionally whitened, and those already at risk of sensitivity. Pregnant women should avoid these products to limit the fetus’s exposure to chemicals. Choose only whitening toothpastes that carry the American Dental Association’s Seal of Acceptance.

If you already have dental problems, such as gum disease or tooth sensitivity, ask your dentist which toothpaste might be best for you. He or she may recommend a toothpaste formulated for sensitive teeth. You can help prevent gum disease by eating a healthy diet, not smoking, and flossing at least once a day with unwaxed floss, which many dental experts believe can remove more plaque and dental debris.

When flossing, be sure to get underneath the gum line to scrape the tooth surface. Ask for instructions from your dental hygienist; you should be seeing one twice a year to have your teeth and gums cleaned. (Be sure to also check this Ultimate Guide To Healthy Teeth.)

ANDREW WEIL, MD, is founder and director of the Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine and clinical professor of medicine at the University of Arizona. For more information, go to DrWeil.com.”

End of article.

Really Dr. Weil? It’s only toxic in large doses? That is almost laughable! Why would you still be promoting this toxic waste product as good for people?  Listed on most toothpastes now are a warning:

“If you accidentally swallow more than used for brushing, seek professional help or contact a poison control center immediately.”

Many dental products contain dangerously high levels of fluoride. For years, manufacturers and dentists failed to warn consumers about the risks from ingesting these products. Although the FDA now requires manufacturers to warn consumers that fluoride products are poisonous when swallowed, manufacturers and dentists are still using these products in ways that expose consumers and patients to potentially toxic levels of fluoride.

Fluoride Toothpastes

  • The vast majority of toothpastes now contain fluoride.
  • Although research suggests adult-strength fluoride toothpaste (1,100-1,450 ppm F) can reduce tooth decay, this potential benefit comes with the risk of disfigured teeth.
  • Use of fluoride toothpaste during childhood is a major risk factor for dental fluorosis, particularly for children who brush before the age of three and who live in areas with fluoridated water.
  • Children who swallow fluoride toothpaste can reach fluoride levels in their blood that exceed the levels that have been found to inhibit insulin secretion and increase blood glucose in animals and humans.
  • All fluoride toothpastes sold in the U.S. must now include a poison label that warns users to “contact a poison control center immediately” if they swallow more than used for brushing.
  • Just one 1 gram of fluoride toothpaste (a full strip of paste on a regular-sized brush) is sufficient to cause acute fluoride toxicity in two-year old child (e.g., nausea, vomiting, headache, diarrhea).
  • In 2009, U.S. poison control centers received over 25,000 calls  related to excessive ingestion of fluoride toothpaste, with over 378 users requiring emergency room treatment.
  • In adults, fluoride toothpaste can cause skin rashes around the mouth known as perioral dermatitis as well as canker sores.

Fluoride “Supplements”

  • Fluoride “supplements” are tablets, drops, or lozenges are designed to provide a substitute fluoride exposure for children living in areas where fluoride is not added to water. Unlike other dietary supplements, fluoride supplements cannot be purchased over the counter. They are only available by prescription.
  • Fluoride supplements were introduced in the 1950s on two incorrect assumptions: (1) fluoride is a nutrient and (2) fluoride is effective when swallowed.
  • Despite being prescribed by pediatricians and dentists for over 50 years, fluoride supplements have never been approved as either safe or effective by the FDA.
  • As conceded by a pro-fluoride researcher, “virtually none of the early fluoride supplement studies would be published today, because of methodological and other shortcomings.” (Riordan 1999).
  • Modern research has consistently shown that children who use fluoride supplements have a much higher rate of dental fluorosis than children who do not. By contrast, the evidence that supplements reduce tooth decay has recently been described by pro-fluoride researchers as “poor,” “inconsistent,” and “weak.”
  • Even the American Dental Association (ADA) and other pro-fluoride organizations no longer recommend fluoride supplements for most children. The ADA does not recommend fluoride supplements for infants under six months of age. After six months of age, the ADA only recommends supplements for children who are at “high risk” for cavities.
  • Some children who take fluoride supplements can develop allergic reactions, including skin rashes, gastric distress, vomiting, and headache.
  • Although fluoride supplements were only intended for children living in non-fluoridated areas, surveys have shown that some dentists prescribe supplements to children living in fluoridated areas as well. This places children at risk for the most severe forms of dental fluorosis.

For more discussion on fluoride supplements, click here.

Fluoride Gels

“Fluoride Gels” are acidic, highly concentrated fluoride products that dentists topically apply to a patient’s teeth about two times a year. Of all the fluoride products currently used in dentistry, fluoride gels are – without question – the most hazardous. While fluoride gels are designed to be applied “topically” (i.e., directly to teeth), very large quantities of fluoride are absorbed into the body during the treatment. Due to this large systemic exposure, many patients – particularly children – experience symptoms of acute fluoride toxicity, including nausea, gastrointestinal pain, and/or vomiting within an hour of the treatment. Gastric distress is not the only side effect. Fluoride gels produce an enormous spike in blood fluoride levels for up to 14 hours, exposing every tissue in the body to fluoride concentrations that have been can damage, in short-term exposures, the kidney, the male reproductive system, and glucose metabolism. Although the dental community has taken steps to reduce the amount of fluoride that gets into the blood from fluoride gels, the extent of fluoride exposure from these gels continues to remain excessive and toxic. Due to the conspicuous absence of safety studies, however, the public health consequences from the dental community’s 40-year experiment with fluoride gels remains a disturbing mystery. Read More.

Other Fluoride Products

For information on other fluoridated products, including self-applied gels, fluoride varnishes, and fluoridated salt, click here.